Aller au contenu
Livraison offerte · Droits et taxes d’importation inclus · Retours sous 60 jours
0

Is a Yogurt Maker Worth It? Cost per Jar, vs Instant Pot and Oven, and Who Should Skip It

November 18, 2026

Six glass yogurt jars with lids on a light oak counter, one open with yogurt and blueberries

You're standing in the kitchen aisle with a yogurt maker in one hand and a tub of store yogurt in the other, and you're trying to decide which one is the better buy. So, is a yogurt maker worth it? It comes down to two questions. How much yogurt does your household really get through, and does anything you already own hold milk at a steady 110°F for a few hours? If you eat yogurt most days and nothing in your kitchen does that job, the machine pays for itself. If you buy one tub a week, or you own an Instant Pot with a yogurt button, keep your money.

The short version

  • It's worth it if you get through about a quart of yogurt a week, want jars you can grab from the fridge, and own no appliance that holds 100–115°F.
  • On a $79.99 yogurt maker, break-even lands between roughly 7 and 18 quarts of homemade yogurt, depending on what you would otherwise buy.
  • An Instant Pot with a Yogurt function, an oven with only the light on, or a thermos will do the same job for nothing.
  • Skip it if you want big strained batches of Greek yogurt or you dread washing six small jars.

What does a yogurt maker actually do?

Less than the box suggests. Yogurt sets when live cultures work on warm milk, usually at about 110°F (43°C) for 4 to 10 hours, and the machine's whole contribution is keeping that warmth steady. It won't heat your milk to 180–185°F beforehand, cool it to 108–115°F, or revive a tired starter. All of that happens on the stove, before the jars go in. If you haven't done it before, our guide to making yogurt in a yogurt maker walks through each step.

What you do get is a steady temperature, a timer, and usually a row of individual glass jars that go from the machine straight into the fridge. Our Youlva Yogurt Maker with 6 Glass Jars has a digital panel for time and temperature, 20 W PTC heating, six lidded glass jars and a transparent cover so you can see the batch without lifting anything. The listing doesn't give the jar volume, the temperature range or the longest timer setting, so read the manual in the box before you plan a recipe around any of them.

How much does homemade yogurt cost per jar?

Cheaper, yes, but by less than most roundups promise unless you normally buy organic or premium. An older Kitchn comparison priced a 32 oz tub of store yogurt at $3.99, about $0.50 per half-cup, against $0.24 for homemade, and still told readers to buy it if they only had standard brands to choose from. Heal With Food runs the numbers for organic: $0.37–0.54 a cup homemade, $1.66–3.10 a cup in the shop. The Kitchn prices are years old, so read them as a ratio, not a quote.

Here is my own arithmetic on those published figures: the $79.99 price divided by what you save per cup. Put your own supermarket prices in.

Scenario Saving per cup Cups to break even Quarts to break even At 1 quart a week
Standard yogurt (Kitchn ratio) about $0.52 about 154 about 38 about 9 months
Organic, low saving (Heal With Food: $1.66 − $0.54) $1.12 about 71 about 18 about 18 weeks
Organic, high saving ($3.10 − $0.37) $2.73 about 29 about 7 about 7 weeks

Power use won't change the sum: twenty watts for eight hours is 0.16 kWh, about 3 cents at 17 cents per kWh. The formula to keep is $79.99 divided by (what you pay per cup in the shop minus what a cup costs you at home) gives the cups you need to make before the machine is paid off.

Yogurt maker vs Instant Pot, oven and thermos

Read a few Reddit threads and the verdict is hard to miss. In r/Frugal one commenter says all a yogurt maker does is keep milk at around 105–110°F, and others get there with a sous vide machine, a beer cooler or a dark oven. They're right. What's left is whether a dedicated machine earns its counter space.

Method Cost if you already own it Batch size Temperature control Best for
Yogurt maker with jars $79.99 for a new one 6 jars Set on panel Daily single portions, a free multicooker
Instant Pot or multicooker with a Yogurt function Nothing Several quarts Preset, adjustable on some Big batches and Greek straining
Oven with the light on Nothing A pot or jars Varies by oven, test first Trying yogurt before buying anything
Insulated flask or cooler Nothing Small Retains heat, no control Occasional small batches

Crock & Culture says that if your Instant Pot has a Yogurt button, you don't need a second machine, and that checking the control panel is the first thing to do. I agree. A dedicated maker earns its place in two cases: you want portioned jars, or you don't want your main cooker tied up for an afternoon. A word on our own range, too: our ceramic slow cooker and our rice cooker don't list a yogurt mode, so don't count on either as a stand-in.

What do yogurt maker owners complain about?

Mostly the same few things. Six small jars means six small things to scrub after every batch, and six is also a ceiling, so a big family would be running the machine all the time. Greek yogurt is awkward, because you have to tip each jar out to strain it and then refill. An r/KitchenPro owner said condensation under the lid ran back into the jars and thinned the yogurt, and said winter and summer batches behaved differently on the same settings. Other owners in that thread put the result down to the starter and the milk brand more than the machine.

What should you look for when buying one?

Start with steady heat, then capacity, then the timer. Ferment Calculator's guide makes the same call: consistent temperature matters more than brand or price. Check whether the temperature is adjustable or fixed, whether the timer switches the unit off when it ends, how big the jars are, and whether they are glass with lids. The shut-off matters more than it sounds. Food & Wine flagged a basic Euro Cuisine model with no automatic shut-off, which keeps fermenting and turns tangy if you're out when it finishes.

Model Price Capacity Controls
Euro Cuisine YMX650 $59.99 7 × 6 oz jars 15-hour timer, automatic shut-off
Youlva Yogurt Maker with 6 Glass Jars $79.99 6 glass jars with lids Digital time and temperature, 20 W PTC
Luvele Pure Plus $109.95 2 L glass container 36-hour timer, 78–122°F in 2° steps, auto switch-off

Ours sits in the middle. Against the cheapest jar machine you get time and temperature set on one panel. It won't give you the single big container that makes straining Greek yogurt simple. Luvele's Pure Plus has one, for $109.95.

Who should buy one, and who should skip it?

It suits you if yogurt is a daily habit, you pack lunches, you like knowing exactly what's in the jar, and no multicooker with a yogurt mode is hiding in your cupboard. It doesn't suit you if you eat yogurt now and then, you already own an Instant Pot with the function, your counter is already crowded, or you mostly want thick Greek yogurt by the quart. Before you spend anything, make one quart in your oven with only the light on, and put a note on the door so nobody preheats it. Check it with a thermometer after an hour. If the jars are empty within a week and you want to make more, buy the machine. If the batch is still sitting in the fridge, you've just saved $79.99.

Youlva portable blender 630 mL

Yogurt smoothies

Portable Blender, 630 mL

USB-C rechargeable, for fruit and yogurt drinks. $39.99. See how to make a smoothie in a portable blender.

View product
Youlva ceramic slow cooker

Warm breakfasts

Ceramic Slow Cooker & Steamer, 1 L

Porridge to serve under your yogurt, with a 24-hour delay timer. $69.99. See how to use a ceramic slow cooker.

View product

Yogurt maker FAQ

Is a yogurt maker worth it?

If you eat yogurt most days and like portioned jars, yes. On an $79.99 machine you break even after roughly 7 to 18 quarts, depending on whether you'd otherwise buy organic or premium. If you eat it now and then, an oven or an Instant Pot does the same job.

Do you need a yogurt maker to make yogurt?

No. Yogurt needs a steady 104–113°F for several hours. An Instant Pot with a yogurt function, an oven with the light on, a heating pad or a thermos can supply that. A dedicated maker adds consistency and ready-made jars.

Yogurt maker vs Instant Pot: which is better?

If your Instant Pot has a Yogurt button, use it. It makes several quarts and strains easily. A yogurt maker wins for single jars and for keeping your main cooker free.

How much does a yogurt maker cost?

Basic jar models list at about $60, like the Euro Cuisine YMX650 at $59.99. Premium water-bath models such as the Luvele Pure Plus are $109.95. The Youlva Yogurt Maker with 6 Glass Jars is $79.99.

Do yogurt makers make Greek yogurt?

They make regular yogurt. For a Greek texture, chill it and strain it through cheesecloth. Small jars make that awkward because you pour each one out, so a single large container suits Greek yogurt better.

Does a yogurt maker use a lot of electricity?

No. At 20 W for eight hours it uses 0.16 kWh, which is about 3 cents at 17 cents per kWh.

Can you make yogurt in a slow cooker or rice cooker?

Some appliances have a yogurt mode, so check the control panel. The Youlva ceramic slow cooker and rice cooker don't list one.

Ready to set up a homemade breakfast routine? Everything is in one place.

Shop cooking & food prep

Sources

Product details checked against the Youlva listings on 18 November 2026.

Votre panier

Votre panier est vide

Trouvez quelque chose pour votre cuisine du quotidien.

Découvrir les appareils